Note: This is Part 1 of our water quality series. After reading this, see Part 2: Choosing the Right Water Filter for guidance on carbon vs. RO systems. For skeptical analysis of water industry claims, check out our January deep-dive: Water Gadgets That Promise Miracles.
The Legal Truth: U.S. Tap Water Is Safe for Most People
The EPA Safe Drinking Water Act sets strict limits on over 90 contaminants. Public water systems test regularly and are required to meet federal standards. The numbers back this up: 93% of U.S. public water systems meet those standards consistently, and official sources like Mass.gov and TapWaterData confirm that municipal tap water is safe for healthy adults in the vast majority of American cities.
Here's an important fact many people don't realize: American public water systems undergo more rigorous testing than bottled water manufacturers. Municipal supplies are monitored continuously; bottled water is tested less frequently. So from a regulatory perspective, your tap is likely safer than what you buy at the store.
That said, "safe" and "optimal" aren't the same thing. The question isn't whether tap water will kill you today. It's whether it's the best water for your family's long-term health, taste preferences, and peace of mind.
The Reality Check: Legacy Infrastructure and Emerging Contaminants
Even if your water treatment plant sends out perfectly clean water, three major issues can degrade it before it reaches your tap:
1. Lead From Old Plumbing
Homes built before 1986 (before the Lead and Copper Rule took effect) are particularly vulnerable. Lead pipes, solder, and brass fittings were standard. Even "good" water from the municipal system can leach lead as it sits in your home's pipes overnight or travels through corroded infrastructure.
Lead is especially concerning for children under 6 and pregnant women—it affects brain development and IQ. The EPA's action level is 15 ppb (parts per billion), but there's no truly "safe" threshold. If your home was built before 1986 or you're unsure, testing is cheap ($20–30) and worth doing.
2. PFAS: "Forever Chemicals" That Don't Go Away
PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) are synthetic chemicals used in non-stick cookware, food packaging, fire-fighting foam, and waterproofing. They don't break down in nature or in your body. Once they're in groundwater, they stay there—accumulation is the risk.
The EPA didn't set enforceable limits on PFAS until 2024, and only for a handful of the thousands of PFAS variants in use. Many utilities are still catching up on testing. If you live near an airport, military base, industrial zone, or area with PFAS-contaminated groundwater, this should concern you.
3. Nitrates and Chlorine Byproducts
Agricultural runoff and aging infrastructure introduce nitrates—a particular concern in rural and farming regions. Chlorine disinfection, while essential for killing pathogens, creates taste and odor issues that turn people away from tap water. Some worry about chlorine's long-term effects, though current science says the exposure levels are safe.
Microplastics are also increasingly detected in water supplies, though their health effects are still being studied.
The Geographic Reality: Some Places Have More Problems Than Others
Texas, Ohio, Florida, and parts of the Midwest struggle with higher contamination rates. But even "good" cities like Boston and New York have neighborhoods with lead and PFAS issues. And a town 30 miles away from another might have dramatically different water chemistry.
The bottom line: Where you live matters. Your water today might be different from your neighbor's, and different from what it was five years ago.
How to Check Your Water: The Consumer Confidence Report
Every public water utility is legally required to publish an annual Consumer Confidence Report (CCR)—essentially your city's water quality scorecard. This is your first stop for actual data about what's in your water.
How to Find Your Report
- Search "[City Name] water quality report" or "[City Name] CCR"
- Visit your city or county's water utility website
- Use EWG's Tap Water Database (ewg.org/tapwater) for historical data and analysis
- Check TapWaterData (tapwaterdata.com) for interactive maps showing what's been found in your area
Key Metrics to Look For
TDS (Total Dissolved Solids): Measured in ppm (parts per million). This includes minerals, salts, and other dissolved matter. Below 300 ppm is soft water; 300–500 ppm is normal; above 500 ppm is hard water. Hard water isn't unsafe, but it affects taste, appliance lifespan, and may warrant filtration.
Lead or Copper Violations: Any mention of these should trigger action. If your home is more than 20 years old, ask for a lead test. Some utilities offer free testing; if not, budget $20–30 for a kit.
PFAS Detections: More cities are testing for this now. If present—especially in any amount—reverse osmosis filtration becomes medically justified. Some states (Michigan, New Jersey) have stricter PFAS limits than the EPA.
Nitrates, Arsenic, or Radium: These appear in certain regions. Nitrates are common in agricultural areas; arsenic and radium in some western and rural groundwater areas. All three are concerning enough to warrant activated carbon or RO filtration.
Health Risks: Who Should Be Most Concerned?
Children under 6: Their developing brains are sensitive to lead. Even low-level exposure affects cognitive development.
Pregnant women: Contaminant exposure during pregnancy affects fetal development.
People with compromised immune systems: Those with HIV/AIDS, undergoing chemotherapy, or on immunosuppressant drugs should consider additional precautions. Cryptosporidium and other pathogens can trigger serious illness.
People in contamination hotspots: If your area has known lead, PFAS, or agricultural chemical issues, filtration makes sense even if you're otherwise healthy.
Everyone else: U.S. tap water is safe. Whether you want to optimize it further is a personal choice.
The Numbers: Why Many Americans Filter Their Water Anyway
About 50% of American households use some form of water filtration. That's not because tap water is failing EPA standards—it's because people want to optimize taste, address specific concerns, or reduce exposure to contaminants that the EPA hasn't yet regulated.
For example, PFAS has been accumulating in groundwater for decades. The EPA finally set limits in 2024, but many municipalities are months or years away from full compliance. Smart people test their water, find out what's actually present, and then decide whether to filter.
What to Do: A Decision Framework
Step 1: Get your CCR and check EWG's database. Spend 20 minutes researching what's documented in your area. Is there anything flagged?
Step 2: If nothing is flagged and you like the taste, you're done. Tap water is safe. You don't need to filter.
Step 3: If you see issues or want peace of mind, test your home's water. A $20 TDS meter or a $100–150 professional test gives you actual data, not guesses.
Step 4: Based on what you find, decide on filtration. Taste issues? A $30 pitcher works. Lead or PFAS detected? You need a more serious filter. We cover filtration options in detail in our companion article on choosing the right water filter system.
Key Takeaways
- Yes, U.S. tap water is legally safe. The EPA standards are strict, and 93% of systems comply.
- But "safe" doesn't mean "perfect." Aging pipes, PFAS accumulation, and emerging contaminants are legitimate concerns.
- Your water quality depends heavily on where you live and how old your home's plumbing is.
- Check your Consumer Confidence Report (free) to see what's actually documented in your area.
- Test your home's water if you have concerns—especially for lead if your home was built before 1990.
- Filtration is a personal choice based on your local water quality, health status, and preferences. Make the choice based on data, not fear.
Further Resources
- EPA Safe Drinking Water Act Standards
- EWG Tap Water Database - See what's been found in your area historically
- TapWaterData - Interactive maps of water quality by region
- Find your local CCR: Search "[City Name] water quality report" on your city's website
- CDC Drinking Water Resources
Affiliate Disclosure
Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you purchase through them, Nexairi may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and resources we believe provide genuine value.
